What will the future hold for the deserts of the
world? Based on the foregoing analyses, we
can assert with some confidence a number of
simple predictions: deserts are and will remain
constrained in their productive potential by their
very nature - the widely varying conditions of the
desert ecosystem, the scarcity of water, and the
oscillating resource variability. This basic nature of
deserts will not change in the forseeable future.
However, global climate change, coupled with
increased population pressure, particularly in the
desert margins, montane areas and wetlands, is
likely to affect the more productive desert areas
and pose some new and significant threats to
biodiversity and sensitive endemic species. By
contrast, the hyper-arid cores of the desert biome
- the vast wilderness of the "deep" desert - are
going to be less affected by mounting pressures on
their fragile biological resources. Water depletion,
on the other hand, as well as salinization of
irrigated agricultural soils, are likely to continue as
two of the main environmental problems in many deserts, encouraged by modern technologies for
groundwater prospecting and pumping. A sort of
modern itinerant agriculture has already emerged,
where large barren areas of salinized agricultural
soils are left behind as groundwater resources
become exhausted and agricultural operations
move on to new lands and to new untapped
aquifers.
These predictions, however, are not fixed and
unchangeable. The scenario analyses discussed
in the previous sections show that there is a wide
range of possible outcomes for deserts, an array
of alternative futures. Whether deserts will follow
a path of intensive development, industrial-scale
agriculture projects and mega-cities attracting
massive immigration - a vision that has been
called, somewhat sarcastically, the "Cadillac
Desert" (Reisner 1986) - or an alternative path of
sustainable development, spurred by a "sense of
place" and prioritizing the desert environment and
the traditional culture of local communities, will be
largely determined by our common visions and
collective action taken to fulfil them.
In reality, current development in many deserts
seems to suffer from a lack of vision altogether.
Few, if any, coordinated programs exist for either
development or conservation of the land. The
unique values and limitations of the desert are
rarely acknowledged. Development schemes,
such as programmes for irrigated agriculture or
mass tourism, tend to spring up haphazardly with
no attempt to coordinate them or to plan for their
long-term sustainability. Immigration to the desert
is often random and opportunity-driven, and new
settlements sprawl over valuable landscapes
and create problems for water supply and waste
management. Without proper planning and a vision
of sustainability, traditional lifestyles atrophy and
indigenous knowledge is lost, victims of short-term,
ephemeral economic projects.
So what is to be done; what vision should be
pursued for the successful long-term development
of deserts, especially in developing countries?
Quite clearly, a continuation of the energy- and
water-intensive development model will lead to
even more severe water depletion and degradation
than is observed today, followed by potential
conflict over water resources among users,
escalating costs of supply, and the continuation
of a non-renewable model in which water, often
under immense subsidies, is, paradoxically, used
for low-value purposes. At the other extreme,
increased isolationism with exclusive reliance on
traditional knowledge runs the risk of losing access
to new sustainable technologies and might lead to
diminished opportunities for younger generations,
and, eventually, to reduced livelihood and
economic development options.
A new, more balanced vision is needed, where
deserts and their inhabitants are valued both by
governments and civil society; where sustainability
and the well-being of desert people are given highest
priority; where desert development is guided by
a long planning horizon and based on an acute
understanding of the limitations and potential of
these very unique environments; where market forces
are harnessed to promote a desert-compatible
development, such as low-impact services or hightechnology
development; where traditional livelihoods
are given the opportunity to survive with dignity; and
where wetlands, oases, desert mountains and other
environments at risk are protected.
Decisions can and should be made not to
change the desert, but to live with it and
preserve its resources for the future. The active
participation of community groups in each
desert for the development of a common vision
is a fundamental condition for the successful
formulation and implementation of policies towards
an environmentally sustainable future. Desert
peoples can, and should, take charge of their own
development, plan for risks, and adapt to changing
conditions while preserving their deep connections
to these remarkable landscapes. The challenge
remains to harness not only local, but also global
policy mechanisms and market incentives to
develop a viable future for our deserts, where both
the successful protection of the environment and
economic development opportunities are achieved. |