The Criteria/Indicators Used in Evaluating Success Stories

Land-use:

  • Appropriateness of the innovations; 
  • Effectiveness and long-term durability of soil and water conservation measures;
  • Suitability of actions to protect and rehabilitate the vegetation cover and measure of its biological diversity;
  • Level of use of biological methods to improve soil fertility and control pests;
  • Innovations that have significantly improved water availability and quality;
  • Sustainability of exploitation of the natural resource base and of the improved livelihoods of the community.

Social and economic aspects:

  • Level of economic and social benefits accrued;
  • Cost effectiveness in labour time and maintenance of innovations;
  • Community involvement in activity planning and implementation;
  • Community contribution to activities in labour time and inputs;
  • Rate and degree of adoption of innovations at community level;
  • Social capital enhancement;
  • Contribution to strengthening of local social structures;
  • Extent of adoptions of approach innovations and by surrounding communities;
  • Sustainable benefits accruing to the wider community in terms of infrastructure, facilities, organizations and social development;
  • Project contribution to community empowerment in economic and social spheres;
  • Degree of community commitment to sustainable resource development e.g. taking ownership and responsibility for resource management;
  • Rate of progress in land adjudication and resolving land tenure issues and the effect on local community action;
  • Project effects on local shelter, sanitation, water supply and health.

 

Policy related issues:

  • Degree of government support and commitment for project activities and their replication;
  • Establishment of enabling institutional frameworks at local level;
  • Effectiveness of existing institutional frameworks in resolving land and tenure issues;
  • Degree of adoption of public policy that decentralizes control and eliminates undue interference in the individual’s management of his/her natural resources;
  • Degree of influence over positive changes in national land use policy development.

For more information on success stories or    request for reports please contact:

Coordinator, Success Stories Initiative Social Dimensions and Sustainable Practices

Dryland Ecosystems and Desertification Control Programme Activity Centre (DEDC/PAC) United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP)        P.O Box 30552, Nairobi, Kenya Tel:(254-2)-623261;       Fax:(254-2)-623284; E-mail: elizabeth.migongo-bake@unep.org

IFAD

Programme Director and Deputy to the Assistant President Economic and Policy Recource Strategy Department International Fund for Agricultural Development (IFAD) 107, Via del Serafino 00142, Rome, Italy                              Tel: (39-6) 54591                                              Fax: (39-6) 5043463                                      E-mail: IFAD@Ifad.Org